The governance and funding structure of privacy-focused cryptocurrency Zcash has once again been thrown into sharp relief following a major restructuring proposal by Zcash Community Grants (ZCG). The committee formally suggested redirecting approximately $124 million in existing and future treasury funds toward mining rewards. However, the initiative has quickly ignited fierce debate across the digital asset ecosystem, drawing sharp criticism from prominent industry figures who argue that the plan fails to address deeper, long-standing concerns regarding transparency, accountability, and the oversight of multi-million-dollar developer treasuries.
On Thursday, ZCG outlined a preliminary plan in a public forum post to transfer 36,200 ZEC—valued at approximately $46 million at the time of writing—from its roughly 91,500-ZEC treasury directly into the Network Sustainability Mechanism (NSM). The NSM is designed to reserve and allocate coins for future block rewards, effectively bolstering the economic security of the Zcash network by incentivizing miners. Should the community vote to approve this specific transfer, the ZCG committee would retain a smaller operational balance of about 55,200 ZEC, which is worth roughly $70 million based on prevailing market prices.
Beyond the immediate transfer of existing treasury assets, the preliminary proposal introduces significant adjustments to the project’s future funding pipeline. ZCG proposed forgoing approximately 62,000 ZEC, representing roughly $78.5 million in future scheduled allocations. Furthermore, the group intends to taper its remaining funding structure until the upcoming network halving in 2032. Combined, these comprehensive adjustments would redirect roughly 98,000 ZEC—valued at an estimated $124 million—toward future block rewards and network sustainability initiatives.
Under the current protocol arrangements, ZCG’s automatic allocation of newly minted tokens is officially scheduled to sunset in 2028. The alternative framework put forward by the committee would instead extend a reduced level of funding for an additional four years, pushing potential structural changes further into the next decade. Emphasizing that the current publication serves only as a preliminary framework, ZCG noted that a comprehensive, formal proposal will be brought forward for broader community consideration and debate before any final decisions are made.
Despite the committee’s stated intent to address community concerns regarding an oversized treasury, the announcement immediately drew sharp pushback from influential voices in the broader cryptocurrency landscape. Helius co-founder and CEO Mert Mumtaz took to social media to voice his disapproval, describing the proposal as "nowhere near good enough." Mumtaz argued that the ZCG treasury remains excessively large and reiterated his stance that significant funding and governance decisions should be directly accountable to individual ZEC token holders rather than centralized committees.
The debate quickly escalated when Gemini co-founder Tyler Winklevoss weighed in, questioning the professionalism and accountability of the committee following an interaction on social media. Winklevoss highlighted a reported instance in which a ZCG committee member unfollowed Mumtaz on the X platform after the latter criticized the proposal. According to Winklevoss, such conduct demonstrates a lack of the maturity and professionalism required to oversee a multi-million-dollar treasury valued at over $100 million.
This latest friction arrives on the heels of a separate, earlier proposal introduced by Zcash co-founder Sean Bowe. Bowe previously called for an outright end to ZCG’s automatic 8% share of newly issued ZEC tokens, suggesting that the entirety of those funds be redirected to the NSM while leaving the existing accumulated treasury untouched. The convergence of these competing proposals underscores a growing appetite within the Zcash ecosystem to re-evaluate how developer funding and network security rewards are balanced, particularly as institutional interest grows, evidenced by recent regulatory filings for a Winklevoss-backed Zcash exchange-traded fund seeking a Nasdaq listing.

