16 Nov 2026, Mon

Coinbase, Kalshi, and Four Other Firms Back CFTC in High-Stakes Lawsuit Over Stock Perpetual Futures

A heavyweight coalition of cryptocurrency exchanges, prediction markets, and prominent trading firms has intervened in a high-stakes federal lawsuit, throwing its weight behind the United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in an escalating battle over single-stock perpetual futures.

According to a proposed amicus brief shared on Monday by Coinbase legal representative Molly Abraham, the coalition comprises a diverse and influential group of market participants. Alongside cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase and prediction market platform Kalshi, the filing is backed by Payward, the parent company of Kraken; major proprietary trading firms DRW Holdings and Jump Trading; and crypto-focused investment company Paradigm Operations. Together, these entities are urging a federal court to accept their brief in support of the CFTC, arguing that stock perpetual futures firmly fall within the scope of existing United States futures laws.

The legal filing arrives on the heels of a significant judicial development. Just days prior, a federal judge signaled that the CFTC had likely overstepped its bounds by permitting single-stock perpetuals to trade as security futures. The unfolding legal battle carries profound implications for the domestic financial landscape, as it could ultimately determine whether US-regulated exchanges are permitted to offer retail traders derivative contracts that track individual equities without a fixed expiration date.

Why Stock Perps Face Intense Regulatory Scrutiny

The controversy began to crystallize on November 3, when the CFTC announced that single-stock perpetual futures—commonly referred to as stock perps—could officially begin trading on US-regulated exchanges for the very first time. The decision marked a notable expansion in the types of derivative products accessible to domestic market participants, blending elements of traditional equity investing with the perpetual mechanics popular in digital asset markets.

However, the regulatory green light was swiftly met with institutional pushback. The Capital Markets Alliance Association (CMAA), a newly formed trade and advocacy group representing traditional financial market participants, filed a lawsuit against the CFTC challenging the agency’s authority to permit the trading of these contracts. The CMAA counts established traditional finance heavyweights among its members, including prominent institutions such as Cboe and Citadel Securities.

At the heart of the dispute is the fundamental nature of the financial instrument itself. Stock perpetual futures allow traders to speculate on the price movements of individual underlying stocks without requiring them to own the physical shares. Unlike traditional futures contracts, which carry a predetermined expiration date that forces settlement or rollover, perpetual futures feature no fixed expiration date, allowing positions to be held indefinitely provided the trader maintains adequate margin.

The CMAA argues that because these contracts lack a fixed expiration date, they do not properly function as traditional futures. Instead, the association contends they should be regulated as security-based swaps—a distinct category of derivatives linked to stocks or other securities that is primarily overseen by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Security-based swaps are subject to substantially tighter regulatory restrictions, particularly regarding their availability and marketing to everyday retail traders.

The coalition of six companies backing the CFTC vehemently disagrees with this interpretation. In their proposed amicus brief, Coinbase, Kalshi, Payward, DRW Holdings, Jump Trading, and Paradigm Operations argue that a fixed expiration date is not a statutory prerequisite for a contract to qualify as a security future. Under their reading of the law, security futures properly fall under the joint regulatory oversight of both the CFTC and the SEC, meaning the CFTC acted well within its legal purview when it authorized the trading of the contracts.

Judge Questions CFTC Authority But Denies Immediate Trading Halt

The legal arguments presented by the CMAA found a receptive audience in the courtroom of US District Judge Valerie Caproni. Following the trade group’s initial complaint, Judge Caproni issued an assessment indicating that the plaintiff was likely to succeed on the merits of its claim that the CFTC had exceeded its statutory authority by allowing stock perpetuals to trade as security futures.

In her preliminary evaluation, Judge Caproni noted that the contracts appeared to align more closely with the definition of swaps rather than security futures. This judicial observation cast a noticeable shadow of doubt over the legal interpretation relied upon by the federal commodity regulator when it approved the new class of derivatives.

Despite expressing skepticism regarding the CFTC’s regulatory reach, Judge Caproni ultimately denied the CMAA’s request for a temporary restraining order. The judge concluded that the trade group had failed to demonstrate the requisite standard of imminent, irreparable harm that would justify halting the markets while the litigation moves forward. Consequently, the decision left the CFTC’s trading approvals intact, allowing single-stock perpetual futures to continue trading on US-regulated exchanges as the broader lawsuit proceeds through the federal court system.

The legal contest is expected to advance rapidly. The CMAA is scheduled to file its official reply to the CFTC’s opposition to a preliminary injunction, setting the stage for further judicial scrutiny over the winter as both sides battle for control of the regulatory framework governing modern retail derivatives.