19 Nov 2026, Thu

S&P Global Ratings Keeps Tether’s USDt at Lowest Stability Score Amid Rising Exposure to Riskier Assets

S&P Global Ratings has opted to keep Tether’s USDt stablecoin pinned at the lowest possible tier on its stability assessment scale, pointing to a growing concentration of riskier, more volatile assets within the token’s underlying reserves.

In a formal evaluation report published on November 18, the credit rating agency assigned USDt a stability score of 5, which designates a "weak" capacity to maintain its strict one-to-one peg with the United States dollar. The assessment remains entirely unchanged from the rating agency’s previous evaluation conducted in November 2025, signaling persistent concerns among traditional financial analysts regarding how the world’s largest stablecoin manages its multi-billion-dollar balance sheet.

At the core of S&P’s cautious stance is the rising share of alternative holdings within Tether’s reserve portfolio. According to the report, higher-risk assets—a category that encompasses physical gold, Bitcoin, public equities, secured loans, and corporate bonds—accounted for roughly 28% of the total USDt in circulation as of September 30. This figure represents a noticeable upward tick from 24% recorded during the same period a year earlier.

The rating agency warned that this structural allocation leaves the stablecoin vulnerable to sudden market downturns. "A significant drop in会的 value of these assets could lead to USDT being undercollateralized," S&P cautioned in its comprehensive analysis, emphasizing that a major correction in cryptocurrency markets or equities could theoretically compromise the token’s ability to redeem every digital coin for a full U.S. dollar.

Tether, however, has fiercely pushed back against the methodology used by the traditional financial rating agency, arguing that the framework itself is fundamentally flawed rather than the company’s reserve management strategy. In a statement provided to Cointelegraph, the stablecoin issuer dismissed the assessment by drawing a parallel to historical financial oversights. "The problem is S&P’s framework, not our reserves," Tether stated, adding pointedly that "their own history shows the underlying problem," while referencing The Big Short, the acclaimed film chronicling the systemic failures that precipitated the 2008 global financial crisis.

The dispute highlights a long-standing ideological and operational chasm between traditional credit rating agencies, which rely on rigid regulatory frameworks and conservative liquidity definitions, and the rapidly evolving digital asset sector. Tether’s latest reserve report for the period ending September 30—which was independently attested by accounting firm BDO—painted a picture of a heavily capitalized entity. The attestation revealed approximately $191.5 billion in total assets against roughly $183.5 billion in liabilities, yielding a surplus of approximately $7.95 billion in excess assets designed to act as an internal buffer against market shocks.

Despite acknowledging these substantial excess reserves, S&P maintained its floor rating. The agency noted that while its ongoing review identified additional operational and structural weaknesses within Tether’s corporate setup, it refrained from making any further downward adjustments simply "because our assessment cannot be lower than 5."

S&P Questions Reserve Oversight Safeguards

Beyond the asset composition of the reserves, S&P’s November report trains a critical eye on the regulatory oversight framework governing Tether, particularly following the company’s corporate relocation to El Salvador in January 2025.

Tether invokes The Big Short in swipe at S&P over USDT reserve risks

The rating agency evaluated the National Commission of Digital Assets of El Salvador (CNAD), the principal regulatory body tasked with supervising Tether within the Central American nation. According to S&P, the CNAD regulatory framework mandates that 70% of a digital asset issuer’s reserves must be held in instruments capable of being liquidated within a 30-day window. S&P characterized this statutory requirement as overly "broad," noting that such a wide definition legally permits the inclusion of relatively high-risk assets—such as Bitcoin, physical gold, and private loans—within the primary liquidity bracket.

Furthermore, S&P raised alarms regarding the absence of strict regulatory requirements to legally segregate Tether’s reserve assets from its broader corporate balance sheet. In major legacy financial jurisdictions like the United States and the European Union, similar financial institutions are typically required to ring-fence customer reserves to insulate them from corporate insolvency or operational liabilities. Because there is currently no publicly available information detailing how Tether segregates its massive pool of assets, the S&P report asserts that external observers lack vital insight into how these funds are protected from broader enterprise-level risks.

Audit Disclosure Remains a Concern

Transparency and public disclosure continue to represent major friction points between Tether and institutional rating evaluators. In August 2026, Tether made significant headlines by confirming that global audit firm KPMG had issued an unqualified opinion on the company’s 2025 financial accounts, marking what the stablecoin issuer hailed as its first "full independent audit." Tether executives stressed at the time that the official audit thoroughly validated the financial statements consistently produced and published by the firm over the preceding years.

Nevertheless, S&P argued that the existence of an audited statement does little to satisfy institutional scrutiny if the complete documents remain private. The rating agency pointed out that the fully audited statements and the corresponding formal auditor’s report have not been published in full, which severely restricts independent analysts from verifying the underlying financial health and counterparties involved.

Additionally, S&P highlighted that Tether’s reserve reports continue to omit the specific identities of the custodians and financial counterparties holding the stablecoin’s assets. The agency also noted that Tether’s public attestations remain on a quarterly reporting schedule, whereas many competing stablecoin issuers have moved toward more frequent, monthly transparency disclosures.

The friction between Tether’s leadership and legacy financial institutions is well-documented. When S&P issued its initial downgrade and low stability score in 2025, Tether CEO Paolo Ardoino publicly rejected the verdict with characteristic defiance. Writing on social media platform X at the time, Ardoino stated, "we wear your loathing with pride," pointing to the history of traditional financial institutions and past economic collapses as definitive proof that legacy financial systems are fundamentally broken.

Despite maintaining the lowest tier on its stability scale, S&P concluded its November 18 assessment with a nod to Tether’s operational resilience, acknowledging that the stablecoin has maintained a commendable history of price stability, particularly over the preceding 12 months, during which USDt has successfully navigated various market cycles without losing its vital dollar peg.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *