15 Nov 2026, Sun

Why Enterprise Blockchain is Poised for a Comeback After Early Failures

Opinion by Paul Brody, founder and chief executive, Nightfall Networks

Do you remember Pets.com? Back in the heyday of the dot-com boom, the online retailer raised a staggering $110 million from prominent backers, including retail giant Amazon, with a straightforward business model: allowing customers to order pet toys and dog food online for home delivery.

The company ultimately crashed and burned in a spectacular fashion, leaving behind a cautionary tale that became a staple of business school case studies. Everyone seemingly learned a definitive, permanent lesson from its demise: you simply cannot profitably ship a bulky, 50-pound bag of dog food directly to a customer’s front door while maintaining a viable margin.

As online retail entrepreneur Ed Baum famously asked in a 2001 postmortem analysis of the failure: “Did Pets.com’s business plan assume the invention of transporters to magically move bags of pet food without shipping costs?”

Please, whatever you do, do not share that sentiment with the executives at Chewy; they might suddenly realize that their entire multi-billion-dollar business model supposedly doesn’t work. In reality, Chewy reported a massive $12.6 billion in sales alongside $223 million in net income in its latest fiscal year, proving that home delivery of heavy pet supplies is entirely viable under the right conditions.

The genuine lesson of Pets.com was never that shipping heavy dog food was inherently a bad idea. Instead, the real takeaway was that the idea arrived long before the logistics networks, consumer habits, and unit economics required to make it sustainably profitable had actually evolved.

As it was with chew toys and heavy bags of dog food decades ago, so it may very well be with enterprise blockchains today.

Collectively, the broader cryptocurrency and blockchain industry probably incinerated just as much capital trying to force corporate blockchain adoption between 2017 and 2023 as Pets.com burned through in its brief lifespan—perhaps even more. Yet, the dozens of specialized technology startups and corporate consortiums that aggressively pursued enterprise blockchain applications were not entirely delusional. Rather, like the pioneers of online pet retail, they were simply far too early.

Why Businesses Need Enterprise Blockchains

It is not difficult to understand the initial commercial appeal of enterprise blockchain solutions, at least when viewed from a superficial perspective. Nearly all modern enterprise systems tend to experience critical failures precisely at the boundaries where different companies attempt to collaborate and exchange data. Historically, these friction points manifest in two distinct failure modes.

The first is the original, legacy failure mode, where inter-company collaboration information is constantly out of sync across disparate systems. In this fragmented world, enterprise IT systems operate effectively as isolated islands, communicating asynchronously with one another through basic digital text messages, emails, and static spreadsheets. This approach is undeniably cheap and remarkably easy to set up from an administrative standpoint—provided an organization does not mind constantly operating with slightly inaccurate, delayed, or mismatched information.

Enterprise blockchain is going to come back from the dead

The second failure mode swings to the opposite extreme: the costly, real-time proprietary integration. In this scenario, powerful industry leaders politely request—or strongly urge—their key suppliers and strategic partners to join their closed, proprietary, but always-on digital networks. These centralized networks are exceptionally costly to build and maintain, but they function remarkably well once established. Ultimately, they leave participating organizations suffering from a corporate variant of Stockholm syndrome, where businesses gradually grow to appreciate the thoroughness and efficiency of the digital choke-hold they have willingly entered.

Distributed ledger technology initially offered a vastly superior path forward by promising shared information and synchronized business logic across an open, decentralized ecosystem. It pledged to deliver all the operational benefits of a proprietary system in terms of real-time visibility and workflow efficiency, but crucially without locking participants into a single vendor’s ecosystem.

Sometime around 2017, this proposition began to look like an overwhelmingly obvious good idea to corporate boardrooms worldwide. Investment capital poured into the sector at an unprecedented rate, industry consortia were rapidly launched, polished press releases were drafted and distributed to the media, and then practically the entire movement crashed and burned. High-profile enterprise blockchain initiatives like TradeLens, We.Trade, Contour, B3i, ASX Chess, and Everledger all arrived with immense fanfare and subsequently vanished within just a few short years.

Although there is considerable nuance embedded within the specific details of each individual corporate failure, these projects largely shared one critical fatal flaw: they were forced to implement unnatural, convoluted workarounds simply to compensate for the fundamental lack of privacy natively available on public blockchains.

Companies Need Privacy, Not Transparency

No commercial enterprise wants its direct competitors peering into the granular details of its supply chain, proprietary transactions, or operational metrics. During the height of the enterprise blockchain push, this commercial reality meant that organizations typically built private or permissioned blockchains. They then attempted to layer numerous non-blockchain-like mechanisms on top of, and deep within, the network architecture in a desperate bid to keep sensitive business data confidential.

The resulting systems were uniformly slow, excessively expensive, and ultimately failed to gain meaningful, long-term market traction. It is hard to overstate the absolute bloodbath experienced by technology startups and corporate ventures that tried and failed to make enterprise blockchain solutions commercially viable during this era. A quick review of historical records uncovers at least 18 different enterprise blockchain projects that flamed out, including several backed by household names.

Many of these failed ventures boasted heavyweight financial backers, ranging from major global banking institutions like Deutsche Bank and HSBC to dominant technology conglomerates like IBM. However, having pedigreed corporate parents and massive brand recognition made no practical difference. The fundamental lack of native privacy crippled the technology, and the financial results were dismal.

The few survivors of that turbulent era have largely "de-chained" themselves, quietly abandoning blockchain theater and reverting back to traditional software-as-a-service delivery models. Furthermore, many enterprise organizations that tested these permissioned systems as end-users walked away with a deeply cynical takeaway: they tried blockchain, and it simply did not work.

That persistent skepticism is deeply unfortunate, because the technological landscape has fundamentally shifted, and everything is different now.

Blockchains Today Have Scalability, Privacy, and Liquidity

Today’s blockchain infrastructure possesses the scalability that early enterprise networks desperately lacked. Back in 2020, the Ethereum network handled roughly one million transactions per day, and transaction fees—commonly known as gas fees—periodically spiked to between $30 and $50 when network demand surged. In contrast, the vast majority of transactions on modern scaling networks are completed for a fraction of a cent, while overall network capacity is rapidly ramping toward billions of daily transactions. Industry discussions regarding the once-famous blockchain "trilemma" have largely faded into the background because Ethereum has proven it can be both sufficiently decentralized and adequately scaled.

The privacy landscape has undergone an equally dramatic transformation. While absolute privacy remains something that must be actively configured rather than accepted as a default setting, an extensive array of advanced privacy tools and cryptographic systems are now readily available. These range from specialized privacy pools and zero-knowledge rollups to fully fledged privacy-centric chains.

Enterprise blockchain is going to come back from the dead

On top of these developer-driven solutions, the core Ethereum ecosystem is actively implementing a wide range of native tools designed to bake foundational elements of privacy directly into multiple levels of the network infrastructure. The ultimate result of these advancements is that it is now entirely feasible to execute complex business operations at a massive global scale while maintaining an extraordinarily high degree of commercial privacy.

Finally, there is the undeniable power of liquidity and capital. Value is rapidly moving onchain. Regulatory bodies around the globe have increasingly recognized and legitimized stablecoins, triggering an enormous tsunami of financial liquidity. Total transaction volume for stablecoins reached a record-shattering $1.8 trillion in June alone.

When businesses combine the operational advantages of modern blockchains with these digital financial rails, they unlock something that enterprise organizations have never truly possessed before: a unified global ecosystem where companies can not only buy, sell, and physically or digitally move assets, but instantly get paid for them within the exact same transactional flow.

The return on investment yielded by every single component of this modern technical equation is substantial. When combined, these capabilities can generate colossal competitive advantages. Partners at management consulting firm McKinsey discovered that advanced digital supply chain tools could make inventory reductions of 35% to 75% possible simply through vastly superior predictive planning and real-time execution.

More conservatively, based on direct professional experience in the field, simply eliminating the traditional cascades of manual spreadsheets and electronic data interchange messages allows firms to run most standard supply chains with about 20% less inventory while maintaining the exact same high level of customer service. In most major industries, that efficiency translates directly into billions of dollars in liberated working capital.

The operational improvements extend far beyond inventory management. Smart contracts drastically reduce the time required to process complex business contract rules from days down to mere minutes, while cutting administrative overhead costs in half.

As a prominent real-world example, technology giant Microsoft began migrating its expansive Xbox video game network onto smart contracts to handle creator royalties and complex revenue distributions. The transition slashed the time required for partners to access their monthly royalty statements from 45 days down to a staggering four minutes—all while seamlessly processing more than 2 million daily transactions.

Once a company successfully places its inventories, legal contracts, purchase orders, and financial invoices onchain, it gains unprecedented direct access to optimized working capital. When a business can cryptographically prove that a purchase order genuinely originates from a top-tier, highly solvent corporate buyer, it can secure commercial credit at significantly lower interest rates. Similarly, when an organization maintains complete, tamper-proof visibility into inventory levels and real-time delivery statuses, it can factor its accounts receivable immediately and with maximum operational efficiency.

The potential use cases are obvious, and the financial returns are too large to ignore. It is finally time for enterprise organizations to try blockchain again.

About the author: Paul Brody is the Founder and CEO of Nightfall Networks, a specialized blockchain technology company focused on developing robust privacy infrastructure for enterprise users. He is the former Global Blockchain Leader at EY and the former Chairman of the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance.

By Muslim