17 Nov 2026, Tue

Bitcoin Improvement Proposal 110 Faces Steep Hurdles as Mandatory Signaling Phase Begins With Low Miner Support

Bitcoin Improvement Proposal 110 (BIP-110) has officially entered its mandatory-signaling phase at block 961,632, sparking a high-stakes test of network consensus and governance. According to data from the BIP-110 monitor, participating miners signaled support in just 51 of the preceding 2,016 blocks—equating to a mere 2.53% signaling rate. This figure falls drastically short of the 55% threshold required for early activation, casting immediate doubt on the viability of the proposal under current mining dynamics.

The arrival of block 961,632 marked a critical juncture for nodes enforcing the controversial change. These specialized nodes immediately began rejecting any blocks that failed to set version bit 4, while ordinary, un-upgraded Bitcoin nodes continued operating under standard consensus rules, accepting both signaling and non-signaling blocks alike. Consequently, a minority BIP-110 branch briefly emerged following the activation block, though it quickly lost ground and fell behind the dominant, majority-supported chain.

Given the exceptionally low rate of miner participation, analysts note that a sustained rival chain is highly unlikely to maintain momentum without a massive and sudden shift in hash rate support. With relatively little mining power dedicated to the proposal, a separate BIP-110 branch faces the prospect of advancing at a sluggish pace or halting block production altogether. This milestone directly tests whether passionate supporters can successfully advance a contentious consensus modification without broad backing from the mining community, a scenario that threatens to permanently split enforcing nodes from the dominant chain and escalate ongoing debates regarding how Bitcoin’s block space should be utilized.

BIP-110 Seeks Temporary Limits on Bitcoin Data

Authored by pseudonymous developer Dathon Ohm, BIP-110 is designed to impose a series of strict, temporary consensus limitations on the Bitcoin network lasting approximately one year. The core objective of the proposal is to reshape transaction structures

by limiting most new output scripts to a maximum of 34 bytes, capping OP_RETURN data carriers at 83 bytes, and restricting specific data pushes and witness elements to 256 bytes. Additionally, the proposal would temporarily restrict several features associated with the Taproot upgrade, though unspent transaction outputs (UTXOs) created prior to the activation of BIP-110 would be granted an exemption.

Proponents of the measure have argued that these sweeping restrictions are necessary to discourage inscriptions and other forms of non-monetary data usage that have crowded the network. In their view, such data significantly increases long-term storage, state bloat, and bandwidth costs for individual node operators, threatening the decentralization of the network by making node operation increasingly expensive.

However, the proposal has encountered fierce pushback from prominent figures across the Bitcoin ecosystem. Critics, including MicroStrategy executive chairman Michael Saylor and Blockstream CEO Adam Back, have openly rebuffed BIP-110, warning that it risks fracturing the network. Opponents argue that forcing such a contentious change could cause validating nodes to reject valid transactions that are fully permitted under the network’s existing, established rules, thereby creating a dangerous schism within the broader community.

The debate over BIP-110 runs parallel to an ongoing surge in network friction, often referred to by community members as the "spam wars." Recent data indicates that the percentage of Bitcoin nodes running software configured to enforce BIP-110 recently crossed the 2% threshold, reflecting a dedicated, albeit minority, faction of users determined to push back against network congestion caused by non-financial data tokens.

The technical roadmap outlined by BIP-110 utilizes version bit 4 as the designated mechanism for miner signaling. The strict deployment schedule establishes blocks 961,632 through 963,647 as a mandatory-signaling window, during which participating nodes enforcing the proposal automatically reject any incoming blocks that fail to carry the required version bit signal. Looking further ahead in the schedule, the proposal’s specification defines block 963,648 as the official beginning of its locked-in state, while block 965,664 is designated as the point when the actual transaction restrictions and consensus rules would officially take effect.

Aware of the steep resistance from the mining sector, proponents of BIP-110 have also discussed more aggressive fallback measures to ensure the survival of their vision. On August 1, Bitcoin developer Chris Guida rebased preliminary code for an alternative proof-of-work (PoW) change that was originally authored by Bitcoin Knots maintainer Luke Dashjr.

At the time, Guida described the rebased code as an explicit contingency plan in the event that miners overwhelmingly opposed BIP-110, though he emphasized that no formal activation date had been established for the alternative PoW mechanism. As the current signaling window progresses, the Bitcoin community watches closely to see how the standoff between enforcing node operators and the broader mining majority will unfold.